WDW


626

About the Column

For years, Jeff Heimbuch has been writing about Disney. Many of his articles have appeared in Celebrations Magazine. But Jeff has always had a little '626' inside him anxious to come out. Unlike his column's namesake, Stitch, he might not paint the Castle blue, but he will paint the park red with entertaining stories, fascinating insights, and daring ... experiments.

Subscribe to Disney Dispatch Digest

And receive a daily email summary of new stuff on the site.

FROM: The 626 Published Fridays

Review: The Epcot Explorer's Encyclopedia

Last week, I previewed R.A. Pedersen's new book, the Epcot Explorer's Encyclopedia. I think the book is indispensable to those with an insatiable interest in Epcot. The book brims with facts. Let's see what Jeff Heimbuch thinks...

These past few months we've been seeing more and more self-published books by fans and Cast Members about the creation of all things Disney. From in-depth looks at the creation of Walt Disney World to memoirs about years spent working for the Mouse, there is a Disney book for everyone nowadays.

One such recent release is The Epcot Explorer's Encyclopedia by R. A. Pedersen. I've been following the book's progress on Pedersen's Twitter account for the past few months, and now here it is, a book unlike any other, probably the most in-depth guide to Epcot that you will ever find.

One of its main selling points is right in the title: it's an encyclopedia, and that is the best way to describe this book. Actually, that's not entirely true. The author coined the phrase 'epcyclopedia' to refer to his book, and I want to kick myself for not coming up with that clever moniker first.

Jeff Explains...

The Epcyclopedia is is not a book to help guide you through EPCOT; it's an intense history lesson about everything in that park, divided into chapters, one for each attraction and pavilion. The first two-thirds of the book covers Future World, past and present, while the final third is about the World Showcase.

Each section on Future World deals with its various subjects quite well. Pedersen provides a fairly in-depth history about each pavilion, including a scene-by-scene breakdown of almost all of the attractions. Based on intense research and various blueprints and construction plans for each ride, Pedersen takes us through each attraction as a sort of written ride-through, commenting on each scene and offering historical facts and trivia.

Where applicable, multiple ride descriptions are provided for the various updates and upgrades done over the years. This proves true also for such famous 'lost attractions' such as Horizons and World of Motion. There is a heavy dose of nostalgia in the book, and the author has a clear love for the EPCOT of yesteryear, which is not a surprise considering the amount of time and detail he spends on the various attractions.

The sections on the World Showcase are very similar to those of Future World, though truncated. I would have liked to have seen a little more details in the World Showcase chapters, as it is my favorite part of the park. These chapters, unfortunately, are significantly shorter than the Future World chapters, and some are only two or three pages long, not really long enough to provide more than an overview of the pavilion.

I'm not sure if the information just wasn't readily available or not as heavily researched as the sections on Future World. However, Pederson does his best to give a bit of history for each pavilion, including a recount of the trials and tribulations of their creation.

Jeff Cautions...

I mentioned that calling itself an encyclopedia was a good selling point, but it can also be a bit of a downer. At certain points, the book reads like an encyclopedia. Some of the information presented is a bit heavy, and may only appeal to hardcore EPCOT historians.

Unlike other books on the history of the parks, this is not presented as a story, but more as a fact book. Casual Disney fans looking for a breezy read may be a bit put off, but Disney aficionados will appreciate the attention to detail.

A major nitpick I had is not with the information presented, but is one that applies to a lot of self published books. There were quite a few spelling and grammatical errors, some of which made me have to go back and re-read sentences before I understood what was being said. The book would have benefited greatly from having a second set of eyes, or an editor, give it a once over. When the information being presented is this fact-heavy, spelling and grammatical errors make it harder to read and understand. It shouldn't put you off from reading it, though, as the information it contains is worth the effort.

Jeff Concludes...

Overall, I definitely recommend the book. Though it's not without its flaws, it is still a good read for those looking to learn more about what EPCOT used to be and currently is. Again, while it may not be the best for the casual fan, if you're reading this website, chances are you will enjoy the book and the information presented.

The book is available for order through the author's website and on Amazon.

Follow me on Twitter for updates!

More: The 626

Stuff Not to Skip

Comments (8)

I appreciate the balanced review. I've come to expect reviews of Disney books to always be positive. Your major nitpick though isn't really a problem with the book's content, it's more an issue with the book's production, and I don't mind dealing with it. Its' just part of self-publishing. You've explained enough about the book to put it on my must-buy list for next payday.
Sam - 4/22/2011 @ 5:23 PM
I went looking for a sample chapter and found a few pages on Amazon's Look Inside feature. I didn't see any spelling mistakes or grammar errors. I didn't see any pictures either - does the book have any? That would have been a good thing to include in the review.

Honestly, I don't think I'll buy this book based on the several pages that I read. I don't need an EPCOT reference. I appreciate the author's hard work and hope his book does well.
Len Wardour - 4/22/2011 @ 7:19 PM
Sam - Glad you enjoyed the review. Yes, I agree, while my major nitpick irked me, it may not be that big of a deal to others. It is definitely a good reference guide and worth having for the information. I, too, hate the always glowing reviews, so Im glad you appreciate my fair look at the book.

Len - Totally forgot to say something about photos, thanks for pointing that out! No, there are no photographs in the book, it's just text.
Jeff Heimbuch - 4/23/2011 @ 10:28 PM
@Sam: quality control, especially in a book like this, IS important. If the author was sloppy enough not to fix his spelling and grammatical errors, then I have to wonder whether his research was also sloppy, and I'd be less confident trusting what he wrote. Jeff did everyone a HUGE favor by pointing this out because it goes directly to the abilities of the author and how much he cares about doing something write. I'm sorry but just because a book is 'self-published' doesn't mean the author shouldn't meet simple standards.
Jenn - 4/24/2011 @ 1:46 PM
You know, I'd been looking forward to this book, but R.A. Pedersen the author lost my support completely when he made attacks against the reviewer.

I don't consider Jeff's review negative and I might even have bought the book.

Just because somebody self-publishes a Disney book doesn't mean everyone's going to think it's a wonderful thing. Geez, what a sense of entitlement!! Dude- get over yourself! My favorite book, Stephen King's The Stand, has 42 really really negative reviews on Amazon. Happens.
ED C. - 4/24/2011 @ 1:51 PM
I don't know what's up with all this fuss - the guy said that he "definitely recommended this book" despite all the typos. I'm anxious to read some other reviews. The author should be here defending his book if he thinks "definitely recommended this book" isn't good enough.
Anonymous - 4/24/2011 @ 2:38 PM
Jenn - While I definitely agree with you on your points, don't let the lack of editing dissuade you that much. The research presented in the book is top notch, and is chock full of information you probably wouldn't have known otherwise. The problem with the ease of being able to self publish your own material now-a-days is that you can do it instantly. Having a publisher look over your book and publish it gives you the benefit of having an editor go over your work with a fine toothed comb, and making sure everything is in tip top shape. With self publishing, unless you pay for it elsewhere, you obviously don't have that benefit. You can write something, and then as soon as you finish it, release it for sale to the masses. With a little bit of a rewrite and a once over by an editor, perhaps a second edition of this book would make the book more accessible to readers.

Ed - Thanks for your support, I appreciate it! But again, I'd like to say that, no matter what took place between myself and the author, I still recommend the book if you are interested in learning more about Epcot. It's a wonderful resource guide, especially for hardcore Disney fans. And, as a sidebar, The Stand is my favorite book of all time too, despite its many negative reviews!

Anonymous - Thanks for your comment! I agree, I would like to see what other reviews are saying about this book. They can agree or disagree with me, and that's fine by me!
Jeff Heimbuch - 4/25/2011 @ 9:21 AM
All this guy does on Twitter is beg everyone to plug his book!! I'll stick with my Imagineering Field Guide.......
Jimi - 4/30/2011 @ 4:39 PM
What's Your Take?
Name *
Email *(We will keep it secret)
URL
Comment *
Comments are moderated so you may not see yours appear right away.

You won't receive a confirmation but if your comment 'disappears' after you click Send It, then you know we got it. Gotta love the quirks...

Powered by Comment Script